| Wolf Blass Wines | 2001 | Black Label | 56 | Gold |
| Penfolds Wines Pty Ltd | 2002 | Bin 389 Cabernet Shiraz | 55.5 | Gold |
| Majella Wines | 2002 | Malleea | 55.5 | Gold |
| Wyndham Estate | 2002 | Show Reserve Cabernet Merlot | 53.5 | Silver |
| Villa Maria Estate | 2002 | Reserve Cabernet Sauvignon Merlot | 51.5 | Silver |
| Forrest Estate Wines | 2002 | Newton Forrest Cornerstone Cabernet Merlot Malbec | 51 | Silver |
| Stonehaven | 2002 | Wrattonbully Cabernet Shiraz | 51 | Silver |
| The Yalumba Wine Company | 2002 | The Reserve | 51 | Silver |
| Westend Estate Pty Ltd | 2002 | 3 Bridges Durif | 51 | Silver |
| McWilliam's Wines | 2001 | Brands of Coonawarra Patrons Reserve | 50 | Bronze |
| McWilliam's Wines | 2000 | Brands of Coonawarra Patrons Reserve | 49.5 | Bronze |
| Wolf Blass Wines | 2000 | Black Label | 49 | Bronze |
| Ferngrove Vineyards Estate | 2001 | Stirlings | 49 | Bronze |
| Villa Maria Estate | 2002 | Cellar Selection Merlot Cabernet Sauvignon | 49 | Bronze |
| d'Arenberg Pty Ltd | 2002 | The Galvo Garage Cabernet Sauvignon Merlot Petit Verdot | 48.5 | Bronze |
| The Yalumba Wine Company | 2002 | The Signature | 48.5 | Bronze |
| Peter Lehmann Wines | 2002 | Mentor | 48.5 | Bronze |
| Lindemans Wines Pty Ltd | 1999 | Pyrus Cabernet Merlot Cabernet Franc | 48.5 | Bronze |
| Redman Wines | 2000 | Cabernet Sauvignon Merlot | 48 | Bronze |
| Jamiesons Run | 2001 | Winemakers Reserve Coonawarra Cabernet Sauvignon Shiraz | 48 | Bronze |
| The Yalumba Wine Company | 2001 | The Reserve | 48 | Bronze |
| Cellarmaster Wines | 2002 | Bleasdale Langhorne Creek Meritage Red Blend | 48 | Bronze |
| The Yalumba Wine Company | 2000 | The Reserve | 47.5 | Bronze |
| McWilliam's Wines | 2001 | Lillydale Estate Cabernet Merlot | 47.5 | Bronze |
| Morris Wines | 2002 | Durif | 47.5 | Bronze |
| Jacob's Creek Wines | 2000 | Limited Release Shiraz Cabernet | 47.5 | Bronze |
| Jacob's Creek Wines | 2001 | Limited Release Shiraz Cabernet | 47.5 | Bronze |
| Lindemans Wines Pty Ltd | 2001 | Pyrus Cabernet Merlot Cabernet Franc | 47 | Bronze |
| The Yalumba Wine Company | 2000 | The Signature | 47 | Bronze |
| Wyndham Estate | 1998 | Show Reserve Cabernet Merlot | 47 | Bronze |
| Kingston Estate Wines | 2001 | Petit Verdot | 47 | Bronze |
| Rosemount Estate Pty Ltd | 2000 | Mountain Blue Mudgee Shiraz Cabernet | 47 | Bronze |
| Cellarmaster Wines | 2001 | Langhorne Creek Area Red Blend | 47 | Bronze |
| Heathfield Ridge Wines | 1998 | Cabernet Shiraz | 46.5 | Bronze |
| The Yalumba Wine Company | 2001 | The Signature | 46.5 | Bronze |
| Tyrrell's Vineyards Pty Ltd | 2002 | Rufus Stone Cabernet Malbec | 46.5 | Bronze |
| Wynns Coonawarra Estate | 2001 | Cabernet Shiraz Merlot | 46.5 | Bronze |
| Kingston Estate Wines | 2002 | Empiric Selection Durif | 46.5 | Bronze |
| Rosemount Estate Pty Ltd | 2001 | Mountain Blue Mudgee Shiraz Cabernet | 46.5 | Bronze |
| Bleasdale Vineyards Pty Ltd | 2002 | Frank Potts Dry Red | 46 | |
| G. Gramps & Sons | 2002 | Cabernet Merlot | 46 | |
| Nugan Estate Pty Ltd | 2002 | Manuka Grove Durif | 46 | |
| Tall Poppy Wines | 2001 | Petit Verdot | 46 | |
| Watershed Premium Wines | 2002 | Cabernet Sauvignon Merlot | 45.5 | |
| Blue Pyrenees Estate | 2000 | Estate Reserve Cabernet Shiraz Merlot | 45.5 | |
| Casella Wines | 2000 | Yendah Vale Vat 010 Durif | 45.5 | |
| Lindemans Wines Pty Ltd | 2000 | Limestone Ridge Shiraz Cabernet | 45.5 | |
| McWilliam's Wines | 2001 | 1877 Cabernet Shiraz | 45 | |
| Morris Wines | 2001 | Durif | 45 | |
| Riverina Estate | 2001 | Warburn Show Reserve Cabernet Merlot | 44 | |
| Fox Creek Wines | 2002 | JSM Shiraz Cabernet Franc | 44 | |
| McWilliam's Wines | 2000 | Lillydale Estate Cabernet Merlot | 43.5 | |
| Penfolds Wines Pty Ltd | 2001 | Bin 389 Cabernet Shiraz | 43 | |
| Cardinham Estate | 2002 | Clare Valley Cabernet Merlot | 43 | |
| Capricorn Wine Estates | 2002 | Red Rock Gravel Pit Red | 43 | |
| Forrest Estate Wines | 2001 | Newton Forrest Cornerstone Cabernet Merlot Malbec | 42 | |
| Forrest Estate Wines | 2000 | Newton Forrest Cornerstone Cabernet Merlot Malbec | 42 | |
| Mills Reef Winery | 2002 | Elspeth Merlot Cabernet | 42 | |
| Pooles Rock Wines Pty Ltd | 2002 | Firestick Shiraz Cabernet Sauvignon | 42 |